Israel and Palestine as one country?
A single state solution is an idea that grew up in the 1920s and then died with the Six-Day War when divisions between the newly-founded Israeli state and the rest of the region were too entrenched for the idea to retain any traction. The political landscape after the war and even today is what many Jewish groups feared when Jewish Zionists were calling for a return to the biblical homeland to develop a Jewish state.
They were far-outnumbered though and for several decades now, hostility and tension have been the hallmarks of politics between Israel and her neighbors with ideologies and perspectives too crystallized for the peace process to make any headway, while the conflicting interests of those involved create a quagmire of goals and wants and needs. Just one facet of the problem, for example, are the settlements, Israelis have created a home for themselves in these areas, while some Palestinians see the land as their homeland.
Ali Abunimah is one of the commentators who believe the Palestinian territories and Israel should become one country that incorporates Jews, Muslims, Christians and every other religious or cultural grouping in the region. He is the author of One Country: A Bold Proposal to End the Israeli-Palestinian Impasse.
Abunimah argues that over 10 million people live in Israel and the Palestinian territories, but that the political situation currently is unbalanced because the authorities in Palestine have no real power and the government of Israel calls the shots. “Half of them are Israeli Jews; half of them are Palestinians. There are about a million people mixed in there who wouldn't fit neatly into either category. And effectively, there's one government that runs the country - and that is the government of Israel.”
Abunimah, like many pro-one state commentators, makes a controversial analogy between the present situation in Israel-Palestine and Apartheid South Africa. During Apartheid, the government of South Africa created black ‘homelands’ that were legally defined as separate entities to the country, had a local authority of their own with little real power and acted as large labor reserves for the economy of South Africa.
The similarities are many and indeed the reference to Apartheid is often invoked in a cheapened fashion in order to make a political point, as Ben Cohen, Associate Director of Communications for the American Jewish Committee, points out when he says “I think the apartheid analogy is wholly inappropriate” adding that “people use the word ‘apartheid’ not because they are concerned about the historical integrity of the analogy, but because they are trying to make a very cheap political point”. There is, of course, a huge difference, Apartheid was a form of governance enshrined in the laws of the former South African state, the superiority of whites over blacks was codified in the constitution of the country. Israel has no such laws.
When the country made moves to unify as a single democratic state, there was considerable anxiety and fear, the white population were afraid they would be punished by the incoming government, which was no longer white-dominated and many international and local commentators were sure the new political system could never work, for the ideological and cultural differences between whites and blacks were too deep.
The same argument exists now as part of the skepticism of a single state stretching from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean. Carlo Strenger, a political commentator for Israel's Haaretz newspaper, argues that the deep-seated differences between the two dominant groups, Jews and Muslim Palestinians, would lead to forms of sectarian division, possibly ethnic violence and the threat of competing battles for power over government.
“That, I think is a very, very bad starting point for a state that is supposed to function with any form of coherency and harmony,” he says. Which is true, the point of a unified country, as Abunimah sees it, is that the government would be a government of and for the people with everyone’s interests represented, such a government, for many, is an impossible ideal. Not least of which, because the single state model works only for the Palestinians and not Israelis, according to Dr. Hussein Ibish anyway.
A senior fellow at the Washington D.C.-based American Task Force on Palestine, Dr. Ibish claims that such a scenario would render Israel non-existent, the state of Israel as Israelis know it would no longer exist because Israel is defined as a democratic Jewish state and if the Palestinian territories and Israel became one state, says Ibish, Israelis would be a minority and so the government would not be Jewish. He is also among the commentators that believe the model would lead to ethnic and sectarian violence like that seen across the Middle East.
South Africa again is an example often pointed to in order to dispel this notion.
The transformation of government that took place in South Africa should not have succeeded given the track record of Africa as a continent. Ethnic violence has been a theme of politics in Africa since colonization brought modern politics to the continent, whites have been driven out of most country’s that came under majority rule. South Africa should, according to statistics and historical examples, be like Zimbabwe, a failed state reliant on foreign aid.
But it isn’t, the people made the transition and unification work. South Africa is the only country in the world to have undergone such a dramatic political change without the massacres and violence that so often accompany these shifts in government.
According to Abunimah, Israel would gain through adopting a single state model. The single state solution would remove the rampant and constant security threat, the religious divisions within the country and the international criticism and isolation that the country is often subjected to.
Like all discussion of the peace process and dissections of possible solutions to the impasse, the single state solution is just a thought exercise. In the current climate, like so many other solutions and compromises, it holds little weight and on the ground it is as solid as a wisp of dust blowing over the separation walls of the West Bank.
Comments
More Middle East News
RSS-
Hezbollah Chief Confirms Syria Presence
The chief of Lebanon's Hezbollah says his group will not stand by while the neighboring government of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad is attacked. Hassan Nasrallah said in a speech Saturday Hezbollah was fighting in Syria to protect Lebanon from the threat of radical Islamists. It was the first time Nasrallah has publicly confirmed Hezbollah's fighting presence in Syria. The ...
-
Leadership Questions Could Hamper Syria Peace Talks
ISTANBUL Next month's Washington - Moscow talks to end the Syrian conflict appear in doubt. The Syrian opposition, at a meeting in Istanbul, remains divided on electing new leadership and it is still unclear if the opposition will attend the talks. Western backers of the opposition are pushing for a broader and more diverse leadership. But attempts to weaken the power of the Islamist ...
-
Obamas drones Gitmo speech welcomed in Pakistan Yemen
President Barack Obama's speech on the use of drones and the fate of Guantanamo prisoners has been welcomed by two key countries affected by the policies - Pakistan and Yemen. At the same time, Pakistani officials criticized Obama for not announcing an end to drone strikes against Islamic militants in the country in his landmark speech on Thursday, as they have long demanded. According to the ...
-
UN agency calls on Syrias neighbours to keep borders open for refugees
24 May 2013 150 The United Nations refugee agency today called on countries around Syria to keep their borders open for refugees, while also stressing the need for "urgent and robust" international support for host countries and aid agencies. There are already over 1.5 million Syrian refugees in Lebanon, Jordan, Turkey and Iraq, according to the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR). ...
-
Syria opposition says kidnapped bishops in good health
In this undated combo picture released by the Syrian official news agency SANA, Bishop Boulos Yazigi of the Greek Orthodox Church, left, and John Ibrahim of the Assyrian Orthodox Church, right, who were kidnapped Monday, in the northern province of Aleppo, Syria. (AP ...
-
Kerry presses Egypt on economic reform says aid depends on it
ADDIS ABABA (Reuters) - Secretary of State John Kerry urged Egypt to act swiftly on economic reforms to secure a $4.8 billion International Monetary Fund loan, saying the measures were needed to get further aid from the U.S. Congress, an American official ...
-
Bahrain Journalists Association Holds Workshop
Manama-May-25(BNA) Bahrain Journalists Association (BJA) held a workshop under the theme "The Official Spokesperson .. Communication Skills with the Media". Culture Ministry Media Advisor Dr. Elie Flouty conducted the training in the presence of officials, journalists, students and public relations officers working in both the public and private sectors. The lecturer stressed ...
-
Hezbollah leader vows victory in Syria for Assad
Hezbollah leader Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah said Hezbollah will fight to keep Syria's Bashar Assad in power. He also said Hezbollah fighers are fighting in Syria against Sunni Islamic ...
-
Hezbollah chief commits to victory in Syria
BEIRUT (AP) -- The leader of Lebanon's Hezbollah militant group vowed to help propel President Bashar Assad to victory in Syria's bloody civil war, warning that the fall of the Damascus regime would give rise to extremists and plunge the Middle East into a "dark ...
-
How Baghdad Fuels Iraqs Sectarian Fire
The Iraqi government has hurled the country to the brink of a new civil war. In under a month, Baghdad launched a vicious assault on a Sunni protest camp, resulting in 44 deaths; executed 21 alleged Sunni terrorists in one day, and suspended the licenses of 10 satellite channels, 9 of them deemed pro-Sunni. Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki’s message to his country’s extremely ...
-
Syria rebels fight on as peace talks pressure mounts
Hezbollah-backed assault on a strategic central town as pressure grew on the opposition to attend a peace conference after the regime agreed to do so. The main opposition National Coalition has met in Istanbul for three days trying to overcome deep divisions over Russian and US proposals to convene a conference to which representatives of President Bashar al-Assad would be invited without any ...
-
State Secy Kerry Tackles Benghazi Syria
U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry promised Monday the Obama administration will do everything possible to protect U.S. diplomats serving overseas, vowing to spare no expense in the effort. "The dangers of diplomacy are not unique to this moment in time: our diplomatic missions didn't become dangerous that night in Benghazi," Kerry told a group of State Department trainees. ...
-
Shaikha Jawaher visits Syrian refugees in Lebanon
Sharjah: Shaikha Jawaher Bint Mohammad Al Qasimi, Wife of the Ruler of Sharjah and Chairperson of the Supreme Council for Family Affairs, recently visited Syrian refugees in Lebanon on her first humanitarian visit following her designation as Eminent Advocate for refugee children by the United Nations High Commission for Refugees ...
-
Mid-air sightseeing tour turns into tragedy in Turkey
ISTANBUL - Two Brazilian tourists died Monday and 23 other people were hurt after two hot-air balloons collided in a beauty spot in central Turkey, officials ...
-
Excerpts Hariri re Hizbullah fighting in Syria.Preventing weapons fromSyria reaching Hizbollah.Israel re weapon to Hizbullah via Syria.Qatar-funded Al Jazeera U.S. launch.Syrian May 20 2013
Excerpts: Hariri re Hizbullah fighting in Syria.Preventing weapons from Syria reaching Hizbollah.Israel re weapon to Hizbullah via Syria. Qatar-funded Al Jazeera U.S. launch.Syrian May 20, ...
-
Syrias Electronic Army attempted attack on Haifas water system
an Israeli official announced Saturday . Professor Yitzhak Ben Yisrael, chairman of Israel's National Council for Research and Development, said that hackers loyal to Assad launched an attack on the computers that control the Israeli city's water. It appears to be retaliation for Israeli attacks on Damascus targets earlier this ...
-
Syria Qusayr under heavy army shelling
The Syrian border town of Qusayr came under heavy shelling on Saturday as the country's army launched a three-pronged attack on the rebel-held town. The army offensive to recapture Qusayr began last Sunday, and the rebels in the town said they ...
-
Terrorists to Get Game-Changing Syria Weapons
JERUSALEM, Israel -- Just days after alleged Israeli airstrikes near Damascus, the head of the Lebanese terrorist group, Hezbollah, says he's ready to receive "game-changing" weapons from Syria. "Syria's response to Israel's airstrikes is to tell Israel that if your goal was to prevent boosting the resistance's capabilities, then take note," Sheikh Hassan ...
-
From Middle East to Eager Park a community is rebranded
Vacant buildings stand in the 1800 block of East Chase St. The block is near Eager Park, a six-acre park that will run through the mixed-use development near the Johns Hopkins Medicine ...
-
Hezbollah Syrian government forces advance in border town
BEIRUT (Reuters) - Syrian government forces and the Lebanese guerrilla group Hezbollah launched a fierce campaign to seize more rebel territory in the border town of Qusair on Saturday, sources on both sides of the conflict ...
-
Equatorial Guinea prohibits Egypt revolt reports
No talk of a Tunisia or Egypt-style revolutions in Equatorial Guinea. These were the orders given to media in the country, which all are controlled by the state or the family of President Teodoro Obiang ...
-
Arab League condemns Israels decisoin to cancel UNESCO visit to Jerusalem
WAM CAIRO: The Arab League has strongly condemned Israel's decision to call off a visit to Jerusalem's historic Old City by the UN's cultural heritage body, and called on major powers to stop backing Israel's aggression on Jerusalem and the Palestinian heritage and territories. The pan-Arab organisation, in a statement, said Israel's decision takes the international ...
Middle East Focus
-
Israel and Palestine as one country?
Peace in the Middle East, it’s as illusive now as it was ten years ago and ten years before that. For many commentators, peace in the Middle East has become a myth, something local and international governments strive for or claim to support without any real hope of realization of the goal. With the current impasse between Israel and the Palestinian Authority ongoing, an old theme is being kicked around again, that of a single state that incorporates Israel and Palestine.
A single state solution is an idea that grew up in the 1920s and then died with the Six-Day War when divisions between the newly-founded Israeli state and the rest of the region were too entrenched for the idea to retain any traction. The political landscape after the war and even today is what many Jewish groups feared when Jewish Zionists were calling for a return to the biblical homeland to develop a Jewish state. Read more
News from around our Network
